An Encylopedia Britannica Company
Ask the Editor

Responding to Questions that use "This" and "These"

Question
What is the proper response to the question, "Are these ___?" Should we say, "They are ____" or is it better to say, "These are _____"? For example, Question: Are these mice? Answer: Yes, these are mice. OR Yes, they are mice. — Katy, Japan
Answer

It's somewhat more common to answer "They are mice" but "These are mice" is also correct.

"These are mice" might be a better answer if something else is in the group of things the asker is referring to. For example, if someone asks "Are these mice?" and they point to a box containing mice and rats, you might answer, "Yes, these (the mice) are mice, but these (the rats) are rats" to differentiate. Otherwise, it's very common to replace a word like this, that, those, or these with a pronoun like it or they, or he or she or they if you are talking about a person/people.

Here are more examples:

Q: Is that a goat?

A: Yes, it's a goat. [less common = yes, that's a goat]

 

Q: Is that your friend?

A: Yes, she is (my friend) [less common = yes, that is my friend]

 

Q: Are these your glasses?

A: Yes, they're mine. [less common = yes, those (glasses) are mine]

 

Q: Are these dishes clean?

A: Yes, they're clean. also Yes, they are. [less common = yes, these (dishes) are clean]

 

Q: Do these shoes belong in the closet?

A: Yes, they do. [less common = yes, these (shoes) do belong in the closet]

 

Q: Is this book yours.

A: Yes, it is (mine). [less common = yes, this book is mine]

 

Q: Can these clothes be donated?

A: Yes, they can be donated. [less common = yes, these clothes can be donated]

 

I hope this helps.

 

For more posts about words, idioms, grammar, and usage, like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter!

Don't forget to subscribe to our Word of the Day e-mails!

Click here to try one of our vocabulary quizzes before you go!

Archive
You can read more articles in the archive.